Saturday, June 19, 2010

I'm wondering what are peoples thoughts concerning these "miracles" that occur (bleeding rocks, extreme healings etc..). I don't believe in any organised religion or there explainations but science can't seem to explain it either??

This is my response to an anonymous question left on the Ask Me Anything page.

Theists want you to believe in miracles. Miracles are the manifestations of God's will on Earth, yet Theists are always willing to say that you shouldn't rely on physical proof to believe in divine power. It is a common human phenomenon called I want my cake and eat it too. I'm going to talk about miraculous healing first and then go onto bleeding "stuff" like rocks, statues, etc.

Let's define the term miraculous healing. Miraculous healing is often depicted as a person in a wheelchair who feels the power of Jesus and leaps up cured. Strangely enough, miraculous healing does not include things like missing arms, legs, eyes, etc.(check out Why Won't God Heal Amputees). One reason why people get better and assume it's by the power of Little Baby Jesus is the Placebo Effect.
The placebo effect is the measurable, observable, or felt improvement in health or behavior not attributable to a medication or invasive treatment that has been administered...
By extension, "fake" surgery and "fake" therapies are considered placebos. (from The Skeptic's Dictionary)
There is a dialogue amongst researchers about how powerful the effect is and how it works, but some belief based healing is going on. It occurs regardless of what the object of belief is (doctor, medicine, or god(s)). 

Another reason for seemingly miraculous cures as well as statues/rocks that bleed blood is that they are shams. Fakes. Hoaxes. Why would someone deceive legions of followers intentionally? I saw Benny Hinn, the miracle wonder healer, on TV a few years ago. He was doing his act in front of a stadium of people. In the midst of some on stage healing he whisked off his jacket and waved it over the crowd. Waves of people fell (literally) under the power of Benny's holy coat and it's wondrous blessings.


I was just on his website (click here to see it) and Mr. Hinn is selling A LOT of stuff!  There seems to be quite a bit of money in the faith based healing. If there is nothing else that we have learned from the Mortgage Crisis and the Oil Geyser in the Gulf is that people do immoral acts to acquire large sums of cash. That's what I suspect from Benny Hinn.

There are those God people who want other people to believe soooo badly that they create Pious Frauds.
A pious fraud is someone whose fraud is motivated by misguided religious zeal (click here for The Skeptic's Dictionary article).
What's a little white lie if it brings people closer to Christ? Fake blood is not hard to make. I made it for my last short film and the ingredients are dark corn syrup and red food dye. I found how to make a statue that cries blood on Religious
In his book "The Unexplained," Doctor Karl P.N. Shuker, mentions a paper by Dr. Luigi Garlaschelli from Pavia University published in Chemistry in Britain. It describes how to make a statue weep.
An except from the book is: "What is needed is a hollow statue made of a porous material such as plaster or ceramic. The icon must be glazed or painted with some sort of impermeable coating. If the statue is then filled up with a liquid (surreptitiously, through a tiny hole in the head, for example), the porous material will absorb it, but the glazing will stop it from flowing out. If the glazing, however, is imperceptibly scratched away on or around the eyes, tear-like drops will leak out, as if materialising from thin air. If the cavity behind the eyes is small enough, once all the liquid has dripped out there are virtually no traces left in the icon. When I put it to the test, this trick proved to be very satisfactory, baffling all onlookers."
I want to add that there will always be stuff we don't understand. Atheists don't deny that. What Atheists don't do is use God as a way to explaining stuff we don't understand yet.


  1. I've noticed something interesting in the arguments given by people defending miracles. Every time I ask a person to tell me about a specific miracle that he or she has experienced personally, they fail to reply. It seems that it's always the case of a person who HEARD about someone who knows a certain someone who experienced a supernatural event.I smile back sarcastically as if trying to tell them that they've countered their own argument.

  2. People are silly. Particularly when it comes to religion.

    They love to throw logic out the window when it comes to wishful thinking.

  3. I think a lot of it attributable to the human brain. If there is one thing our brains excel at it is pattern matching.

    But if you add the superstitious gospel to that then of course there will be apparitions galore. But here is the catch, ever notice every image of Christ or Mary or what have you has European features?

    Thing is, the alleged Christ and both his mom and dad would have been Semitic Jews.

    So the patterns they match come from modern imagery.

  4. My bed started shaking suddenly in the middle of the night, which some people might attribute to supernatural forces, but it turned out to be my neighbors banging the headboard against the wall while they were screwing.


Google+ Badge

Pageviews last month